A Family Operated Agency Serving Clients Needs Since 1864.

Have a question? Give us a call today!
Phone: (800) 777-0044

About US

Founded in October 1864, The Mazzeo Agency began as a real estate and insurance brokerage, operating in Greenpoint, Brooklyn, NY. We incorporated in 1908, and in 1965 Robert L. Mazzeo, CLU, became sole owner and sold the real estate operation. Soon thereafter, the Agency moved to the Financial District of Manhattan. Mary J. Mazzeo joined the company in 1984 as administrator and insurance broker. The following year, The Mazzeo Benefits Agency, Inc. was formed as an extension of the original company, to highlight the Employee Benefits effort, independent of the property and casualty business. The New Jersey office was opened during that time.


The Mazzeo Agency continues to be a family operated company, and we are very proud of the community we have built with our loyal customers and carriers over the past 150 years.  Our business is built on the foundation of service, and you can be assured that we will work with you to meet your insurance needs today and in the future. In fact, you can be certain that we are available to serve you when you need us. Not only will our staff design an affordable program to meet your unique requirements, but we will also provide timely reviews of your coverage as your circumstances change and offer claims assistance to ensure fair, prompt claim settlements. Contact us today to learn more about everything we have to offer!

Why Partner With an Independent Agent?

We are not employed by an insurance company– we work for you. As an independent agent, we represent a carefully selected group of financially sound, reputable insurance companies and place your policies with the company offering the best coverage and the most competitive price. There are many benefits of working with an independent agent.

As Your Independent Insurance Agent:

  • We are licensed professionals with strong customer and community ties.
  • We give you excellent service and competitive prices because we can access the insurance coverage from multiple companies.
  • We are not beholden to any one company so you won’t have to change agencies if your insurance and service needs change.
  • We assist you when you have a claim.
  • We are your consultant, working with you in determining your needs.
  • We offer you a choice of insurance plans and programs.
  • We focus on value, finding the best combination of price, coverage and service.
  • We offer one-stop shopping for a full range of insurance products for you and your business.
  • We periodically review your coverage to keep up with your changing insurance needs.
  • We are available to give you individual attention and meet with you face-to-face.

Customer satisfaction is the key to our livelihood, since serving you is our most important concern.

Our team is standing by to help you.

Business People Working on Documents

Contact Us NJ

1 Bethany Rd. Suite 50
    Hazlet, NJ 07730-1667
Tel: (732) 344-5154
Fax: (732) 344-5155

Monday-Friday: 9am - 5pm
Saturday & Sunday: Closed

Contact Us NY

110 Wall Street, 11th Floor NY,
NY 10005

Tel: (800) 777-0044
Fax: (732) 344-5155

Monday-Friday: 9am - 5pm
Saturday & Sunday: Closed

Copyright©2017 Mazzeo Agency. All rights reserved. Privacy Policy